To
P. Chidambaram
Minister of Finance DT .21 FEB.2014
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES;
GOVT.OF INDIA
19,Safdarjang Road, New Delhi.
SUB: 1) DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF CASTE OF SH,BALDEV RAJ MAHI P/F 52135 EX. MANAGERPNB LDM OFFICE HOSIRPUR ,PUNJAB.
2) SH.B.R.MAHI (PF52135) , EX MANAGER, LBO , PNB, HOSHAIRPUR PREVIOUS PNB USMANPUR WRONGLY CHARGE SHEET .DT5.OCT.2009.
SIR,
YOUR KINDLY REFER TO LETTER NO 20/24/2013DATED 28 JANUARY,.2014 AND MY LETTER DATED 8/11/2013AND PAD /DAC/15035 DATED 3/01/2014 ON THE ABOVE SAID SUBJECT .IT IS SUBMITTED AS REVIEW PETITION AS UNDER
1) I WAS WRONGLY CHARGE SHEET BY THE DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY CUM DGM/CIRCLE HEAD PNB HOSHAIRPUR.
2) SH.JAGDISH LAL SENIOR MANAGER / ENQUIRY OFFICER DID NOT GIVE AMPLE OPPORTUNITY TO DEFEND CASE
3) DGM HOSHAIRPUR DID NOT PROVIDE ME THE PNB RELEVANT DOCUMENTS FOR SUBMITTED REPLY TO THE CHARGE SHEET
4) ENQUIRY OFFICER DID NOT CONSIDER THE POINTS RAISED BY ME WHILE SUBMITTING THE REPLY OF PRESIDING OFFICER .
5) ENQUIRY OFFICER WRONGLY PROVED CHARGES AGAINST ME WITHOUT HAVING ANY EVIDENCE. HE WORKED UNDER THE PRESSURE OF SENIOR OFFICERS DGM & AGM .I WANT TO 1 & 2 INSTANCES OF DISCRIMINATION i)ENQUIRY OFFICER PROVIDE SOME CHARGES WHEN I WAS ON LEAVE AND WAS ON A PERSONAL FOREIGN VISIT .
II) ENQUIRY OFFICER WRONGLY PROVED CHARGE AGAINST ME WHEN I WAS POSTED AT AN ANOTHER BRANCH OFFICE RAHON INSTEAD OF B/O USMANPUR ON 17/05/2005 ,CHARGE SHEET ED BRANCH .
6 ) THE DISCIPLINE RY AUTHORITY DGM ,CIRCLEHEAD PNB HOSHIARPUR PUNJAB DID NOT CONSIDER THE POINTS RAISED BY ME AGAINST THE ENQUIRY REPORT AND ACTED IN PREJUDICE MANNER. THE D.A/ DGM,CIRCLES HEAD PNB HOSHIARPUR HAS VIOLATED THE PROVISION OF PAD NO.16 DATE 10 JANUARY 2011,HE HAS NOT IMPLIED ON MY CASE
7) THE DGM/DA/ CIRCLE HEAD HOSHIARPUR UNDER THE PRESSURE OF SH. K. BHSKAR CVO HEAFOFFICE PNB VIGILANCE CELL NEW DELHI WHO WAS RETIRED ON AN 30 JUNE 2011 AND SIGNED MY PUNISHMENT ON 25JUNE 2011 ,5DAYS BEFORE HIS RETIREMENTS INSTEAD OF HIS OWN INDEPENDENT DECISION OR OPINION SH.K.BHASKAR RETIRED CVO PNB NEWDELHI WAS DISHONEST PERSON WHO SIGNED UNFAVORABLE DECISION WHO WAS NOT GIVEN GRATIFICATION , OR BRIBES TO BHASKAR.
8) I FILED AN APPEAL THE GM PAD SECTION PNB NEWDELHI TO SET ASIDE THE DECISION OF DA /DGM/HOSHIARPUR .
9)THE WRONG FACT S SUBMITTED BY DGM/DA/ CIRCLE HEAD PNB HOSHIARPUR TO TAKE DECISION ON APPEAL AND NO INDIPENDENT DECSION WAS TAKEN ON THE BASIS OF MY SUBMISSION S.
10) THE GM ALSO DID NOT CONSIDER IT ON MERITS AND DECIDED AGAINST ME ON THE BASIS OF WRONG FACT S SUBMITTED BY LOWER AUTHORITIES .
11) I FILED A REVIEW PETITION BEFORE THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF PNBHEAD OFFICE NEWDELHI .AGAINS DECISION WAS TAKEN ON THE WRONG
SUBMISSION OF LOWER AUTHORITIES AND DID NOT CONSIDER THE FACTS STATED BY ME IN REVIEW PETITION AND NO INDEPENDENT DECISION WAS TAKEN BY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF PNB HEAD OFFICE NEWDELHI.
ON THE WHOLE THE CASE AS DECIDED BY DISPLINARY AUTHORITY ON THE BASIS OF WRONG ENQUIRY REPORT REMAIN UPTO LEVEL OF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR EVEN THE CHARGES WHICH WERE NOT PROVED AGAINST ME IN THE ENQUIRY REPORT WERE PROVED AGAINST ME BY D.A. WHILE SUBMITTING HIS REPORTS TO LIVE GM AND E.D.
IT IS HUMBLY PRAYED THAT JUSTICE SHOULD BE DONE TO ME ON THE BASIS THE FACTS PRESENTED BY ME BUT WERE NOT CONSIDERED BY GIVING PUNISHMENT TO ME
THANKING YOU
YOURS FAITHFULLY
Baldev Raj Mahi,
Baba Deep Singh Nagar,
Saloh Road,
Backside K.C.Palace, Nawanshahr (Punjab)
Distt.Sahid Bhagat Singh Nagar
09501302675 (M)

To
P. Chidambaram
Minister of Finance DT .21 FEB.2014
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES;
GOVT.OF INDIA
19,Safdarjang Road, New Delhi.
SUB: 1) DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF CASTE OF SH,BALDEV RAJ MAHI P/F 52135 EX. MANAGERPNB LDM OFFICE HOSIRPUR ,PUNJAB.
2) SH.B.R.MAHI (PF52135) , EX MANAGER, LBO , PNB, HOSHAIRPUR PREVIOUS PNB USMANPUR WRONGLY CHARGE SHEET .DT5.OCT.2009.
SIR,
YOUR KINDLY REFER TO LETTER NO 20/24/2013DATED 28 JANUARY,.2014 AND MY LETTER DATED 8/11/2013AND PAD /DAC/15035 DATED 3/01/2014 ON THE ABOVE SAID SUBJECT .IT IS SUBMITTED AS REVIEW PETITION AS UNDER
1) I WAS WRONGLY CHARGE SHEET BY THE DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY CUM DGM/CIRCLE HEAD PNB HOSHAIRPUR.
2) SH.JAGDISH LAL SENIOR MANAGER / ENQUIRY OFFICER DID NOT GIVE AMPLE OPPORTUNITY TO DEFEND CASE
3) DGM HOSHAIRPUR DID NOT PROVIDE ME THE PNB RELEVANT DOCUMENTS FOR SUBMITTED REPLY TO THE CHARGE SHEET
4) ENQUIRY OFFICER DID NOT CONSIDER THE POINTS RAISED BY ME WHILE SUBMITTING THE REPLY OF PRESIDING OFFICER .
5) ENQUIRY OFFICER WRONGLY PROVED CHARGES AGAINST ME WITHOUT HAVING ANY EVIDENCE. HE WORKED UNDER THE PRESSURE OF SENIOR OFFICERS DGM & AGM .I WANT TO 1 & 2 INSTANCES OF DISCRIMINATION i)ENQUIRY OFFICER PROVIDE SOME CHARGES WHEN I WAS ON LEAVE AND WAS ON A PERSONAL FOREIGN VISIT .
II) ENQUIRY OFFICER WRONGLY PROVED CHARGE AGAINST ME WHEN I WAS POSTED AT AN ANOTHER BRANCH OFFICE RAHON INSTEAD OF B/O USMANPUR ON 17/05/2005 ,CHARGE SHEET ED BRANCH .
6 ) THE DISCIPLINE RY AUTHORITY DGM ,CIRCLEHEAD PNB HOSHIARPUR PUNJAB DID NOT CONSIDER THE POINTS RAISED BY ME AGAINST THE ENQUIRY REPORT AND ACTED IN PREJUDICE MANNER. THE D.A/ DGM,CIRCLES HEAD PNB HOSHIARPUR HAS VIOLATED THE PROVISION OF PAD NO.16 DATE 10 JANUARY 2011,HE HAS NOT IMPLIED ON MY CASE
7) THE DGM/DA/ CIRCLE HEAD HOSHIARPUR UNDER THE PRESSURE OF SH. K. BHSKAR CVO HEAFOFFICE PNB VIGILANCE CELL NEW DELHI WHO WAS RETIRED ON AN 30 JUNE 2011 AND SIGNED MY PUNISHMENT ON 25JUNE 2011 ,5DAYS BEFORE HIS RETIREMENTS INSTEAD OF HIS OWN INDEPENDENT DECISION OR OPINION SH.K.BHASKAR RETIRED CVO PNB NEWDELHI WAS DISHONEST PERSON WHO SIGNED UNFAVORABLE DECISION WHO WAS NOT GIVEN GRATIFICATION , OR BRIBES TO BHASKAR.
8) I FILED AN APPEAL THE GM PAD SECTION PNB NEWDELHI TO SET ASIDE THE DECISION OF DA /DGM/HOSHIARPUR .
9)THE WRONG FACT S SUBMITTED BY DGM/DA/ CIRCLE HEAD PNB HOSHIARPUR TO TAKE DECISION ON APPEAL AND NO INDIPENDENT DECSION WAS TAKEN ON THE BASIS OF MY SUBMISSION S.
10) THE GM ALSO DID NOT CONSIDER IT ON MERITS AND DECIDED AGAINST ME ON THE BASIS OF WRONG FACT S SUBMITTED BY LOWER AUTHORITIES .
11) I FILED A REVIEW PETITION BEFORE THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF PNBHEAD OFFICE NEWDELHI .AGAINS DECISION WAS TAKEN ON THE WRONG
SUBMISSION OF LOWER AUTHORITIES AND DID NOT CONSIDER THE FACTS STATED BY ME IN REVIEW PETITION AND NO INDEPENDENT DECISION WAS TAKEN BY EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF PNB HEAD OFFICE NEWDELHI.
ON THE WHOLE THE CASE AS DECIDED BY DISPLINARY AUTHORITY ON THE BASIS OF WRONG ENQUIRY REPORT REMAIN UPTO LEVEL OF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR EVEN THE CHARGES WHICH WERE NOT PROVED AGAINST ME IN THE ENQUIRY REPORT WERE PROVED AGAINST ME BY D.A. WHILE SUBMITTING HIS REPORTS TO LIVE GM AND E.D.
IT IS HUMBLY PRAYED THAT JUSTICE SHOULD BE DONE TO ME ON THE BASIS THE FACTS PRESENTED BY ME BUT WERE NOT CONSIDERED BY GIVING PUNISHMENT TO ME
THANKING YOU
YOURS FAITHFULLY
Baldev Raj Mahi,
Baba Deep Singh Nagar,
Saloh Road,
Backside K.C.Palace, Nawanshahr (Punjab)
Distt.Sahid Bhagat Singh Nagar
09501302675 (M)